jimmy rollins hall of fame reddit

Rollins has more hits, home-runs, runs scored and more steals. Rendered by PID 22120 on r2-app-0472d8fc68846985e at 2021-03-13 19:41:56.846461+00:00 running 1ebdfbe country code: US. That’s 525 games, 1806 plate appearances, and 405 hits that he compiled during years when he didn’t provide much value at all to the team statistically (acknowledging that he was always considered a great guy to have on the team). This has only continued after his career. All game times are Eastern. He said he wasn’t going to tell me because then I’d know what he thought was smart. Surprised to see that. Rollins’ Hall of Fame case starts with his counting stats. They both have better offensive stats, especially Rollins than a lot of the SS that are in the HOF right now. Career offensive numbers are quite comparable, but there are some notable discrepancies. More From The Good Phight A game happened: Phillies 4, Orioles 4 One other criteria some Hall of Fame voters use is the impact a player made during his career. Loved watching them play, and I still get to see Utley all the time. If there was ever a borderline candidate, J Roll fits that mold. I just don’t see much difference between him and quite a few other shortstops. Vizquels value came from his fielding. BTW, he's 6th all time in games played at the position. I understand your argument, but I’m still not sold on Vizquel. Larkin is still as good a baseline as any when talking about Jimmy Rollins and the Hall of Fame. © 2021 reddit inc. All rights reserved. For more on sports injuries, check out our friends at Sports Injury Alert. No, unfortunately, but he had a great career that will be fondly remembered. 2 seasons over 100 OPS+, Rollins had 6. • Rollins (46.0 bWAR, 16.4 WAA): 12 above-average, 5 below-average. From 2004 to … It sure seemed to help Harold Baines. Posted by 2 years ago. They(OV and JR) weren't hitters like Joe D or Mickey. He was often overshadowed by Derek Jeter, Troy Tulowitzki and Hanley Ramirez at points in his career. The Hall predictors don't include OPS, and so according to them, Rollins is either comfortably in the range, in the case of the Monitor (129 vs. median of 116), or at least at the low end (42 vs. 45). There is also quite a large gap in career WAR, with Larkin having compiled 70.4 lifetime to J Roll’s 46.3. But how many shortstops were even close to hitters like that and if they were, they usually moved to different positions after a while when they got older and lost their defensive skills to play the position. If he makes it with the Giants, it will be the first time in his 17 year career that he hasn't played SS. No way. So excluding the new players on the ballot and the steroid guys, there are a bunch of players more worthy than Rollins -- and probably a few already in the Hall of Fame. I asked him what tweet. National League All-Stars. Rollins was definitely a better hitter. He had 30 HR, over 40 Stolen Bases, over 30 doubles and 20 triples. The guy that really should be in the Hall already is Alan Trammel. [–]baseballonthebrain 0 points1 point2 points 3 years ago (1 child). Hall of Famer Jimmy Rollins. 'The Talk' co-host responds to 'vaccine-shaming' [–]Chicago Cubsronin_d[S] 0 points1 point2 points 3 years ago (1 child). Trammell and Larkin had to wait a few years to pile up enough support. Of all the members of the 08′ squad, Hamels has the best chance at Cooperstown. Guess the Year. Jimmy Rollins played in 41 games for the White Sox last season and batted .221. The Hall of Fame shortstops he compares to best weren’t first-ballot guys. At his peak, Rollins was a Hall of Fame-level player. [–]Miami MarlinsDoctorTheWho 2 points3 points4 points 4 years ago* (0 children). [–][deleted] 1 point2 points3 points 3 years ago (2 children). The fact that Rollins was such a key leader during the franchise’s best run in history will likely help his Hall of Fame case when all is said and done, as will his postseason work overall. Finally, it is important to view Jimmy Rollins the person when considering his hall chances. How can he not be rewarded with a trip to Cooperstown? [–]baseballonthebrain 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago (4 children). JRoll has over 2,200 games at the position. [–]Montreal Exposdavewashere 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). He may not get in at first, but with multiple routes such as the Veterans Committee, I don’t think it’s out of the question to say that Rollins will eventually find his way in. Absolutely he is. Via “Gray Ink”, Rollins has 82 with the average HOFer having 144. He and Honus Wagner are the two SS(and only one other player in the history of the game has done this)that has 9 seasons with at least 30 steals and 50 extra base hits. He's the greatest modern era combo of power and speed for a Shortstop especially considering for as long as he has played the position. Posted on 9 February, 2020 Baseball, Hall of Fame debate. Sure, both were shortstops that won one league MVP and have similar career hits totals. Is Jimmy Rollins a Hall of Famer? I liked Rollins as a player but not a HOF. Tom Tango likes to use Wins Above Average when looking at a player’s Hall of Fame case. Good insight. Rollins is one of three players in MLB history to finish his career with at least 200 home runs, 100 triples and 400 stolen bases. On June 14, 2014, Jimmy Rollins broke Mike Schmidt's record, and became the Phillies' all-time hits leader. His lack of hustle and slightly above average offensive statistics tell me that Rollins is not an all-time great who deserves to be a Hall of Famer. Hamels has had a very long, highly consistent career and is closing in on some surefire Hall of Fame milestones, including 3,000 strikeouts. Hall of Fame Shortstops, by Wins Above Average: Vizquel and Maranville are nearly the same player, statistically. As eluded to before, one of the big things that will work in J Roll’s favor is his legendary status in Philly. If Alan Trammell isnt in its a travesty if Rollins gets in. Here's why. As we continue our series on Hall of Fame ballot previews with the MLB shut down due to the coronavirus pandemic, today we look at Jimmy Rollins. Is Jimmy Rollins hall of fame worthy or just hall of very good? No other shortstop has ever done this and he did it for a team that won the division in comeback fashion. A World Series MVP, for instance, would be a big spur for Jimmy's Hall of Fame case; let's get to work on that. Best-case scenario he's a Veterans Committee inductee a long time from now. “Superfly” Jimmy Snuka has been removed from the WWE Hall of Fame section of WWE.com, and had all mentions of him scrubbed from the … For one, Barry Larkin won 9 Silver Sluggers at shortstop to J Roll’s one. J Roll’s numbers still may not leap off the page in the national sense, but his standing as one of the best players to play for one of the league’s oldest clubs is certainly worth mentioning. The most commonly cited player when it comes to the Hall of Fame chances of Jimmy Rollins is Barry Larkin. However, that line of thinking may be more indicative of Larkin playing his entire career in Cincinnati than anything, because their two careers weren’t that similar. And Jimmy Rollins was one of the most exciting players of our era. Unfortunately, no. Freddy Peralta thrills family with dazzling debut. Jimmy Collins was a star as baseball entered the 20th century, acclaimed by many as the “king of the third basemen.” And while he was a good hitter, finishing with a .294 lifetime average, it was as a fielder he won the headlines. Jimmy Rollins, future Hall of Famer? I mean, does it hurt to be friendly with the people who are eventually going to be making these decisions? As for the postseason, J-Roll is tied with Shane Victorino for the most hits with 47, has the most steals with 11, and is also tied for the lead in games played with 46. [–]baseballonthebrain 0 points1 point2 points 3 years ago (0 children). [–]NC Dinosredltng6 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago (0 children). Rules, features, protocols for 2020 season, Roster, transaction rules for 2020 season. As I said with regards to Cole Hamels, Hall of Fame voting is still a political process that requires a human element. Vizquels value came from his fielding. That said, there is certainly a case for both Jimmy Rollins and Chase Utley. • Nomar Garciaparra (44.2 bWAR, 24.2 WAA): 10 above-average, 4 below-average. Rollins has been featured on postseason panels and has recently done some color commentary with the Phillies. It certainly doesn’t. We’ve seen players unpopular with the writers such as Roberto Alomar have to wait a long time to get enshrined and in some cases, such as Curt Schilling, the question is still looming. I don't think so, but he had more WAR (both Baseball-Reference and FanGraphs) than Omar Vizquel and I've heard people say Vizquel is. I have literally no clue so I'm just looking for opinions and thoughts. Let’s start with the easiest method for determining Rollins’ Hall of Fame candidacy, Baseball Reference’s Hall of Fame Monitor. The case will be very similar for Rollins if he gets in. Rollins obviously won an MVP, appeared in four all-star games, won four gold gloves, ranked third or better in runs scored four times, led the league in triples four times, and also has a World Series ring. I don't think he would make the Hall of Fame (HOF). They are elite Shortstops. The web site, Baseball: Past and Present, does a great job outlining the 50 best players not in the Hall of Fame and is a pretty good guide where some players rate. Rollins of course surpassed Mike Schmidt to become the team’s all time hit leader in 2014, his final season in Philly before being traded to LA in a deal that netted Zach Eflin. Forget that he has 4 gold gloves. When the stadium was empty he would roller skate around the concourse, smoke pot in the dugout and have friends over for parties. An MVP award is something that could make up for where J Roll’s lifetime numbers and other achievements fall short. Outside of maybe three seasons, Rollins has never done much to impress me. Jimmy Rollins Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports 34 players who have ever worn a Phillies jersey while playing professional baseball have been inducted into the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame. [–]Philadelphia Philliestuberippin 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). No one has more, the photograph of longevity and for the most part, especially defensively at a high level. Ultimately, it’s hard not to say Rollins was an all decade caliber player. This metric assesses how likely a player is to make the Hall. The most commonly cited player when it comes to the Hall of Fame chances of Jimmy Rollins is Barry Larkin. They were once winners. 2007 was far and away Jimmy’s best season statistically, a campaign in which he slashed .296/.344/.531, led the league in runs scored, stole 41 bases and hit a career high 30 home runs. Jimmy Rollins' case for the Hall of Fame is interesting insofar as that he has some of the accolades that voters like to see. Vizquel's entry to the hall is up for debate, but Jimmy Rollins should be a first-vote entry. I'm a Phillies fan and JRoll was my favorite player. His prime wasn't good enough or long enough. Larkin also has more RBI’s, a higher OBP and a higher slugging percentage. Underrated strategy: the catcher yelling "swing!". So, while I don't believe in any magic Hall of Fame numbers, if Rollins is in a group with only Jeter and Ripken, he's in tremendous company. Examining The Hall Of Fame Case For Jimmy Rollins, View reality_circuit’s profile on Twitter, New Yorkers Blame “White Nationalism” For Attack On Asian Man Even…, John Fetterman files paperwork for 2022 PA Senate race, PA Secretary of State resigns three months after uncertain election results, Former Rep. Ryan Costello poised for 2022 Senate run, Cindy Marten poised to enter Dept. Some of the factors going into the score are batting average, hits, RBI, home runs, MVP awards, and All-Star appearances. That's MVP stuff. Rollins was definitely a better hitter. Phillies: Is Jimmy Rollins a Hall of Fame-worthy player right now? ‘Absolutely,’ Charlie Manuel says The Philadelphia Inquirer Jimmy Rollins will be on the Hall of Fame ballot later … Rollins is also lucky enough to have played in two enormous sports markets in Philly and LA. A World Series MVP, for instance, would be a big spur for Jimmy's Hall of Fame case; let's get to work on that. ‘Absolutely,’ Charlie Manuel says inquirer.com - Matt Breen. If you ask Phillies fans about him, you will receive rave reviews nearly across the board. Rollins has similar career numbers to Barry Larkin, who is in the Hall of Fame. Only 3 ASGs. Low OBP and aside from 2001, was never that close to the top guy in SB, [–]Texas Rangersleinahtan25 17 points18 points19 points 4 years ago (4 children), [–]Boston Red SoxYoureprobablygay 23 points24 points25 points 4 years ago (2 children), [–]Texas Rangersleinahtan25 4 points5 points6 points 4 years ago (1 child), [–]Toronto Blue Jaysyoboapp 12 points13 points14 points 4 years ago (0 children), [–][deleted] 20 points21 points22 points 4 years ago (0 children), [–]Boston Red SoxChokeuponthebat 8 points9 points10 points 4 years ago (0 children). Speaking of that, he and Chase Utley were the faces and leaders of those Phillies teams that won 5 straight division titles, 2 NL championships and a World Series. Chris and Pop-Pop argue both sides of the coin to ultimately declare whether or not Rollins is a player who will eventually be enshrined in Cooperstown. He wasn’t first ballot, but he made it. Arguably the 2nd best defensive SS behind Ozzie. His defensive runs saved in his prime are high. Omar Vizquel has 2700 games at the position. The official subreddit of the Philadelphia Phillies! No. His impact on the team winning like this speaks for itself. Jimmy Rollins: An exclusive shorstop When baseball fans talk on what makes a ballplayer a Hall of Famer there several common words that appear somehow during the dialogue.